before buying expensive routers check OpenWRT’s table of hardware and buy one that is supported by the current OpenWRT release and has decent specs. There is a detailed installation guide for each supported device in the wiki too so there are no excuses it’s dead simple. Free yourself from stupid hardware manufacturers and their planed obsolescence products.

snd (he/him)
link
fedilink
1
edit-2
1M

I just bought the openwrt one a couple of minutes ago after using networkd+hostapd+nixos as my router for more than 2 years.

I disagree. Your machine should be setup such that you don’t have to trust the network that you connect to.

With multi-layered defense you should protect your network, but not trust that you always succeed.

I don’t see LibreCMC (https://librecmc.org/) mentioned anywhere in this thread, so correct that.

Unlike Open WRT, LibreCMC is recognised by GNU to be a fully free Linux distribution, and you still get the time-honoured LuCi web administration interface.

LibreCMC runs on much fewer devices as OpenWRT, which can be a feature for those who are overwhelmed by the length of OpenWRT’s list.

☂️-
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
24d

deleted by creator

Yea. That is THE one reason why I’d never touch GrapheneOS as long as it only runs on Pixel hardware.

Mikrotik with RouterOS for European-made router without chinese backdoor

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
21M

I honestly don’t know much about Microtik’s RouterOS but in a few occasions I had I realised it is way too complicated for home user and their OS is not FOSS and needs payed license too. I’m sure it’s great once you get the hang of it but it’s unnecessary pain when there is OpenWRT available with a lot of devices you can choose not just one specific manufacturer

Mikrotik is proprietary, and has a bad security track.

This. I cringe whenever I see someone using an ASUS or TPLINK.

ASUS [routers] are fine. I’ve been using them for years (several models, lately their ExpertWifi EBM68). What’s the issue?

Mikrotik is such pain in the dick. Not used them in the last 5 years but hated working with them in the past.

I had a managed switch from mikrotik, returned it. Skill issue. Its good, but the tplink that replaced it worked just as fine for the sameish price and one tenth the hassle.

@fxdave@lemmy.ml
link
fedilink
4
edit-2
1M

I don’t recommend GL.inet routers. I have the Marble and it is slower than my ISPs router. It has a thing called network hardware acceleration, and it breaks my home server. Services just stop working well with it. So I keep it turned off. When I reported the issue they said it is working for them and came up with a completely hypotical setup…

With AdGuard enabled it frequently froze and I had to reboot it. For some reason even without AdGuard name resolution is noticeably slower. Doesn’t matter if I use my ISP’s DNS or not.

Also, DynDNS doesn’t support custom names, so I installed an alternative service for mywire.org.

Overally, this box came with drawbacks, but no doubt about it is hackable in the good way.

I would like to try openwrt’s own router, next time.

Sat
link
fedilink
41M

I remember the majority of routers in the past could not handle many half-open connections which had very negative impact on torrenting. Asus routers were the only ones that didn’t have that limit and i stuck with them since. Is that still a problem that exists?

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
11M

I have port forwarding setup on my devices (Google WiFi running OpenWRT). I can connect to most piers on qbitorrent. My only limit seems to be my bandwidth Which is what we want.

Sat
link
fedilink
1
edit-2
20d

Thank you, though that doesn’t really answer my question. Torrenting also worked back then but it would become slower than a router that could handle more half-open connections. If you have fast peers and a small number of torrents, it would probably not matter, but if you seed 100+ torrents at the same time, you’d notice.

sunzu2
link
fedilink
181M

For the more rookie people, check out routers that are based on openwrt and have rookie GUI.

OpenWRT is great and powerful but unless you are trying to level your networking skills, it can turn into a biatch real quick beyond basic set up.

☂️-
link
fedilink
-1
edit-2
24d

deleted by creator

sunzu2
link
fedilink
21M

You prolly right for the audience here but my comment is going after the broader audience tbh

Imagine a world where normies start using openwrt routers as default 🐸

It just has to work and that product already available, a seach string away

☂️-
link
fedilink
-1
edit-2
24d

deleted by creator

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
61M

That’s interesting like which devices? Could you elaborate

sunzu2
link
fedilink
11M

People mentioned glinet but there are others, I think even linksys and asus has a version if you don’t like China based company.

edric
link
fedilink
9
edit-2
1M

GL.Inet ships their routers with OpenWRT built-in. You no longer need to setup openwrt yourself, and it has a user friendly GUI that allows you to set up most of the basic/standard stuff without having to go into the openwrt interface. They even have easy setup options for the popular VPN providers so you don’t need to upload the wireguard config, you just log in (unless you have custom settings).

Chemical Wonka
link
fedilink
1
edit-2
1M

GL. Inet GUI is proprietary as far as I know

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
01M

Thanks I had no idea that sounds great. I looked online they’re devices are not available at all where I live but that’s may not be the case for other.

Got one of their devices, really happy with it

@modus@lemmy.world
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
1M

Seconded. They seem to have a lot of features that I didn’t expect to have. I also didn’t realize it was OpenWRT until now.

GliNet makes great openwrt based devices, they have their own more userfriendly front end, but allow power users to enable acess to the standard openwrt features and packages under the hood.

drkt
link
fedilink
141M

Also powerful but I reckon if you’re at this level then you already know about it; https://opnsense.org/

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
21M

As a matter of fact I heard about them but I don’t know much about OPNSense. Do they support devices other than ones they sell? They seem to be rather about professional environment not home network am right?

You can use on any computer really (with network connections of course).

I use on a minisforum PC with 2 NICs attached to it. For this solution is usually needed APs (which tends to be better in general, just more expensive). There are people that even use opnsense with proxmox (which is a VERY advanced use case) to have the machine for more things.

One interesting detail: with opnsense you can actually have on the same machine adguard for DNS installed as a service for opnsense (and use opnsense to actually force all DNS to to there, as long is not doh, but that is a bit of a different story).

drkt
link
fedilink
31M

It supports any x86 device you throw at it. I’m running it on a hodgepodge PC I built out of scrap.

I use it too in a VM, but this doesn’t support being installed on routers, right?

drkt
link
fedilink
31M

It doesn’t support being flashed to a low-end commercial router like you’d do with OpenWrt, no. Those tend to require special firmware and binary blobs, hence OpenWrt has to specifically support a model or it likely won’t work. It’s like flashing Android ROMs.

OpnSense is great if you’re in the market for totally owning your own router, though. You can get an N100 box with 2 NICs off of ebay or something and slap OpnSense on that. That’s arguably more FOSS than flashing OpenWrt to a cheap commercial router.

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
31M

Damn I’m sold next step I gonna look into them

I have Opnsense running on a tiny N100 mini PC from AliExpress for myself, but for my elderly parents I have a OpenWRT based solution from Banana Pi. They insist on always switching off their power completely when they leave the house, and I think OpenWRT handles that much better.

Basically OpenWRT is for dedicated, purpose built hardware, highly compact and essentially “embedded”. OPNSense is for running a (potentially much more capable) firewall on x86/x64 (even if it’s a small specimen like N100 or whatever). They fill a somewhat different role.

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
21M

Well explained. I get it now

How does DD-WRT fare? I’ve been using that, but I only have old routers. I mean, old. But I only have mobile data, so they’re mostly for playing around. Except for the one which supports Wireguard in DD-WRT. That’s very useful as a client. Unfortunately, it’s also the least stable one, rebooting every few minutes and eventually ending up in a bootloop after 1 to 2 hours.

I’ve got I think 8 routers now, 6 of them have Wi-Fi, 1 has 802.11n (the unstable one), the rest peaks with 802.11g.

turtle [he/him]
link
fedilink
2
edit-2
1M

I use both OpenWRT for my newer router and DD-WRT for an older router (802.11n) that’s being used for my building’s HOA. Both work great for me. No stability problems. However, I’m not using Wireguard with either of them. It’s mostly fairly basic functionality.

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
21M

Sorry I don’t know much about DD-WRT to be honest. I myself have a Google WiFi mesh pack of three devices which I bought second hand for about 30$. They are excellent value in my opinion so maybe look into that if you’re interested

Any recs for a OpenWRT-supported router? The list is pretty deep

I know openwrt actually realised a openwrt router.

I bought a flint 2 from glinet And it works pretty well

One that supports the latest standards, though I’d suggest a Gl.iNet router if you don’t know much about networking as OpenWRT is quite confusing.

☂️-
link
fedilink
-1
edit-2
24d

deleted by creator

What I did when I was looking for a newer router to run OpenWRT was to look at their supported hardware list, narrow down to the ones with recent WiFi protocol support (in my case, WiFi 6), then compared prices. I was able to buy a used Belkin router for $20 on Ebay that did the trick.

Doomerang
link
fedilink
31M

https://forum.openwrt.org/t/best-newcomer-routers-2024/189050/2 this comes right from their forum and is a good list

sunzu2
link
fedilink
11M

Glinet is leading.

I am surprised considering they are china based. I guess with foss software it aint as much of an issue?

As long as there are no hardware backdoors openwrt should overwrite firmware/software ones.

Well, GL iNet 's router software is based on OpenWRT, so all of their’s. The UI of nicer, so I just leave their version on there; go through the “advanced settings” menu item to get the LuCI interface.

I’m using a Linksys MX4300 I got from woot for like $20, seems pretty good.

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
61M

It comes down to specs and your needs but these are a must in my opinion:

  1. having atleast 128 mb of storage or some way to expand it.
  2. 256 mb of memory or more
  3. suppot WiFi 6 or better 6E or 7
  4. Support for mesh protocols if you need it
  5. Decent multi core chipset if you gonna run intensive tasks on it (like VPNs or DNS filtering) etc… the list goes on but like I said It really comes down to your needs ( on a side note consider read the details and installation guide page before buying some brands and models are easier than others to tinker with for sure)

This is a helpful starting place, thanks!

aprehendedmerlin
creator
link
fedilink
31M

You’re welcome. Sorry I didn’t named some specific devices but that’s because device availability and price changes drastically region to region so something maybe a great deal where I live but that may not be the case for you or the other way around.that said Xiaomi and some Hauwei maybe tp-link devices are the best bang for the buck in my corner of the world look into those maybe that’s the case for you too. Also Here is the new version of the table of hardware with more details

Create a post

A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.

Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.

In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.

Some Rules

  • Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn’t great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
  • Don’t promote proprietary software
  • Try to keep things on topic
  • If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
  • Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
  • Be nice :)

Related communities

much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)

  • 0 users online
  • 124 users / day
  • 1.05K users / week
  • 1.3K users / month
  • 4.58K users / 6 months
  • 1 subscriber
  • 3.85K Posts
  • 97.2K Comments
  • Modlog