Anatomy of Apple's Personal Knowledge Graph — Eighth Rank
8rank.ai
external-link
Every Mac since macOS 13 (allegedly) ships a pair of daemons whose only purpose in life is to build a graph about who you are, whom you know, how those people are related to you and to each other, how you communicate with them, where you go, what you do and when. In this post, we look into how this system works and give you a tool to peek into your own graph.

AI-generated website trash. Find a different source.

This is the original source unfortunately it seems

B-b-but Apple cares about privacy. They would never spy on you like the filthy Microsoft. That’s why I brought an iPhone.

For all the problems of Steve jobs, he at least kept the company fairly honest in this sense. But the instant he died, Tim cook immediately rushed to install PRISM backdoors into all their systems while still carrying the image of privacy.

I need to arrange a meeting with every apple user I know so I can remind them that they’re Tim apple’s wholly owned bitch, I told them so, and they fucking suck.

Can you also talk to my employer’s IT department?

artyom
link
fedilink
1•8d

Yeah my employer updated their app to require Google services and their response to my concern was “sorry, you must sign up to be Google’s bitch if you want to keep working here”

lol you’re Google’s bitch.

artyom
link
fedilink
0•8d

😮‍💨

how does it feel?

artyom
link
fedilink
0•8d

Like a bitch

I mean… they did market this as having your personal context, so I don’t think it is a surprise. The idea is it’s not accessible to anyone but you.

me, and my rightful owners of course.

The data in this case is local on the device, but I agree it’s still an invasion of privacy

Is it? Remember when you couldn’t launch an app on OSX because apple was down for some reason.

No I don’t remember that, but consigning doesn’t require all of your data to be shared remotely, just a few encryption keys. Not even enough to know what exactly you are running (although it’s likely something from the App Store in which case they have records of what you bought or downloaded in the App Store of course).

Apples odd in that they are pretty protective of your personal information, as in they won’t sell it or lets 3rd parties come even remotely close to it, but have very little qualms in abusing it themselves.

Not even Google sells any of your data. They collect data and sell advertising spots but not the data itself.

Selling data only works as a business model if you cannot sell ad spots. That is why news websites have cookie banners with 1000 partners but Google, Facebook, Apple, et al. do not.

they won’t sell it or lets 3rd parties come even remotely close to it

If they secretly let the government double dip, I don’t think I want to trust any other claims they and their marketing makes.

Apple admits to secretly giving governments push notification data - Ars Technica

What are the odds that Google also claims it doesn’t sell your data, it “shares” it.

But would you trust them?

Even Apple is going to listen to the government. They have done things to limit what they can tell them but most people don’t use it. And to be fair so has Google it is why location data is now on device instead of on the cloud with Google.

All cloud operators are beholden to their governments.

@dropdrip@lemmy.ml
link
fedilink
24•
edit-2
9d

I read that Apple was implementing ads in their maps software now. Quick search seems to confirm it. Below is a page blurb originating from Apple’s domain.

Now businesses can run ads on Apple Maps — right where customers are deciding where to go.

My initial comment was just satire, but reading through the document I’m just… tired. This sort of analysis originates from America’s intelligence organizations. It’s not surprising that the technique’s bled into private-business–it always happens. Intel. orgs. create a software solution that solves one of their problems and entrepreneurs within those organizations realize private-businesses have similar problems.

(I will state–because it’s tangentially related–the matrix-protocol originates from individuals linked to mossad. I encourage users not to use matrix.)

Apples not odd. It’s the same as every other technology corporation.

(I will state—because it’s tangentially related—the matrix-protocol originates from individuals linked to mossad. I encourage users not to use matrix.)

Are you referring to the historic link to Amdocs?

Ads don’t violate privacy.

Yes they do

Only personalised ads do. If someone pays to be shown ahead of competitors no matter who’s doing the search, there’s no personalization.

I would argue that it’s bad in a different way. But also, I think non-targeted ads in the internet are very rare

But can be a demonstration of a violation

Also can carry a dangerous payload.

If they were random, sure.

But they’re not.

allegedly

Lemmy:

The website has a TLD from the Caribbean Area, has little to no reference online, barely any trace on social medias, this feels like a sensationalist psy op. Also the website only has 2 articles, this being the second.

The word “whom” appears 9 times in this article. lol

SkaveRat
link
fedilink
7•8d

Anyone got a version without the llm word diarrhea? This is completely unreadable

This is literally an AI artefact. There’s every chance someone reading this understands its contents better than the author. What a joke.

Not surprising. This era of capitalism is built around spying on you in order to find out how to sell you stuff better. We love it.

No, those data centers are for AI - how else will people write articles?

☂️-
link
fedilink
2•9d

there’s what i’ve been saying about apple hardening.

moldy_rice
link
fedilink
29•9d

If you install Linux on it, it fixes it, right?

artyom
link
fedilink
5•8d

Linux is the only true “operating system” at this point, insofar as it just being a platform you use to complete tasks, and not one designed to serve the interests of the corporation selling it to you against your will.

moldy_rice
link
fedilink
1•8d

Minix?

That’s not true, there are also the BSDs.

To answer what other have missed, if you run Linux then that will fix this.

Linux is great for any of the Intel series max, but apple silicone is so new that they’ve barely cracked the surface of M3 full capabilities with any Linux distro.

I will not post a link to it for privacy reasons, but I wrote an article on this the day before the original M1 was announced warning of this situation. Apples move to their own chipset meant that any attempts at maintaining compatibility would always end up behind the curve.

I am surprised that Apple manage to keep their chips constantly changing as much as they do between generations. Most others seem to be on the ‘same but more’ path nowadays but Apple is still shifting the baseline almost yearly.

The real issue will come if they lock down the boot loader.

I will say this, I love my M5 Air and it doesn’t have An Apple Account. Like, at all. Nor did my last M2. Apple allows me more desktop privacy than Ms or Google will, and I don’t have to gut the OS. I’m not motivated to because they make the horsepower available to me.

Every other machine is running some debian/Ubuntu variant today, principally. I got tired of the cat-and-mouse and all of the uosells under the hood of MS, and I just can’t trust Google in this era.

Of the big three I would say that Apple is the lesser of three evils.

Mwa
link
fedilink
1•9d

also PowerPC

You know I thought about that as I was commenting, and also kind of rolled the dice on someone calling it out. And ancient Apple equipment are built like tanks.

But I remember running Minecraft Beta on an ancient iMac G5, and it was too choppy even back in the day. I can’t imagine you being pleasant on one in the modern era.

So I think looking back, I would put a hard limit at only putting machines in service that were manufactured at or after 2012 or so. Get a cute Haswell Mac Mini and call it a day.

If you insisted on vintage Apple hardware older than that, I would recommend getting the system and throwing a Raspberry Pi in there instead. I really wish the G4 lamp Macs would make a come back.

Mwa
link
fedilink
1•8d

If you insisted on vintage Apple hardware older than that, I would recommend getting the system and throwing a Raspberry Pi in there instead. I really wish the G4 lamp Macs would make a come back.

I had a thought before of putting a RPI in there.

Farid
link
fedilink
-6•9d

Apparently you lose a lot of functionality. I wanted to install Linux on my old Intel Mac but the research showed I’m gonna struggle even getting the kb to work, cause it goes through the T2 security chip. This was about a year ago. Hopefully by now people have worked around those issues with Claude.

I have a 2018 Mac mini running Mint. I haven’t had any problems like that.

I had always wondered why so many people have had compatibility issues with Linux systems, that was until I realized that because I am basically a computer scrap-man, I almost always a decade behind and everything had been long hardened by then.

Farid
link
fedilink
3•8d

Mac mini is different, it doesn’t have kbm, touchID etc. I’ve run Ubuntu on older minis as well.

You need a T2 patch and touchpad software, it’s not that hard to get working if you follow the right tutorial

Farid
link
fedilink
2•8d

I know about the patch, but I think back when I checked last, it was in rudimentary state and not very reliable. Hopefully it’s better now. I remember there were more issues, like for sure touchID doesn’t work, but I think there was other stuff, too.

Action Retro recently did a video on this (it works)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_gSSQXiT7A

Farid
link
fedilink
2•
edit-2
8d

I just got suggested this video today! It’s awesome that the progress hasn’t stopped. Once they fix thunderbolt and the mic, I’m installing it for sure. My 2020 Intel Mac isn’t gonna get the next MacOS update anyway.

We had Linux on M1 before Claude was really a thing.

Farid
link
fedilink
1•
edit-2
8d

I’m aware of Asahi Linux. It was mostly unusable for the first few years. Nowadays it runs, I think on up to M2 chips.

Same for Iphones? This says MacOs.

I can promise you if they are really doing it on MacOS they are doing it on iOS

Holy shit.

Is there a file or database that can be deleted now and then ?

you have to hire an aexorcist

Yeah, here is my graph

Do we start measuring from Y=0?

As soon as Asahi ships M4 support I’m relegating macOS to an as-needed partition or VM. I can’t wait, I love the GNOME UI aesthetic. Unforkable software needs to die.

I’d love to contribute to OSS but breaking in to a community, learning a codebase, its dependencies, its build systems, its docs, its community rules, its politics all at once by myself is too much.

Find one issue and fix that. Best way to start. Every little thing helps.

The easy fixes usually get picked up really quickly for projects that magnitude. The hard ones are tough for someone new to the project.

They just said they want to contribute to OSS, there are plenty of smaller projects that need simpler bugs fixed. Then you can keep moving to bigger and bigger projects.

Maeve
link
fedilink
2•9d

Anyone vouching for https://trustworthy.technology/?

They have a bunch of broken links on their site so not a great sign that someone’s keeping up with this project

Maeve
link
fedilink
1•9d

Thank you. 🫠

for as long as iCloud has been a thing, actually.

The only one who can control apple devices is apple

Have said it for ages, it is End to end encryption, the question is if they are the end or you are? Is it Your end to Apple, Apple to them? Plausible but hard to verify.

Apple has always been lying about their “pro-privacy” features. For as long as iCloud has been a thing, they’ve been spying on their users almost as invasively as facebook does

Yep when they control the keys they control the conversation also.

Create a post

A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.

Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.

In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.

Some Rules

  • Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn’t great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
  • Don’t promote proprietary software
  • Try to keep things on topic
  • If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
  • Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
  • Be nice :)

Related communities

much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)

  • 0 users online
  • 108 users / day
  • 246 users / week
  • 454 users / month
  • 1.13K users / 6 months
  • 1 subscriber
  • 5.06K Posts
  • 123K Comments
  • Modlog