/u/outwrangle before everything went to shit in 2020, /u/emma_lazarus for a while after that, now I’m all queermunist!
Yes, any editing done without the author’s consent is a violation of the personal and private creative process. There are obviously degrees of violation, so on the low end there’s other examples you gave like resizing a video or colorizing a photo without permission. Then on the other end we have the fucking nightmare of YouTube changing my face because I’m too ugly.
The point is, you’re defending YouTube for doing something heinous. Do you think this is okay?
YouTube inserting itself into the creative process in an unwanted way is a violation of something that was previously personal and private. The artistic choices a video creator makes are their own, changing them changes the meaning of what they created and violates the authentic connection between the artist and the audience. Imagine if the comments you made on videos were edited to be something else -it’s a violation of our ability to even express ourselves in public. A private decision making process is being taken away from artists.
This isn’t unrelated to privacy.
You might have missed the problem.
We have an authentic connection to the author when we engage with their content, the editing and lighting and scripting is a reality they create and share with us.
What YouTube did was mediate the connection between the creator and the viewers. YouTube destroyed the reality that the author was trying to create for their viewers and substituted its own reality instead.
Okay but now we aren’t really talking about privacy anymore, are we? We’re talking about the monopolization of social media by a few corporations as we’re siloed into platforms. Bad, for sure, but a different problem.
The election interference is coming from inside the house and privacy is only tangentially related to a larger problem.
I’ll continue to be more worried that my DMs will be used to put me in prison.
It wasn’t that long before you were born that the Black Panthers marched in the streets with guns to confront murderous cops.
Things look bad because people here have had it too good for too long. We won the Cold War, it was the end of history!
But the good times are coming to an end and America’s chickens are coming home to roost.
I wonder how many police stations will burn this time.
Do you think that the police need a pretext to become violent?
I’m skeptical of all “outside agitator” narratives that seek to frame uprisings as illegitimate. The fact is, even if he encouraged other people to take direct action, the uprisings were the result of people choosing to take matters into their own hands after that. He didn’t start those fires.
I don’t condone individualistic violence! It doesn’t help and just creates chaos. We should be organized and disciplined, not burning random shit down.
But let’s not pretend the uprising was fake. The purpose of blaming him for all the other protesters taking their own direct action is so people like you are reassured that good USAmericans will never do anything drastic. That’s the actual function of this article.
Things can only get so bad before we hit a breaking point. It will come. Have some revolutionary optimism.
They scanned your message and found you were critical of Israel, a team has been sent to your location to resolve the issue.