TL;DR I am looking for confidential genetic testing, as I am concerned about potential misuse of my genetic information could lead to a conservatorship or loss of autonomy. I am willing to travel, and I would like all records destroyed after testing. I am also open to international options to ensure my privacy.
I’m seeking a confidential method for genetic testing, as I have concerns about my privacy. I reside in the USA and suspect I might have a mosaic genetic condition based on certain phenotype traits I observe. I’m not comfortable with my genetic information being stored in databases or shared, and I’d prefer the lab records, testing data, and results all be destroyed after completion. I’m open to traveling for this testing if necessary, especially since I do not trust US laws to provide adequate privacy protection or the right to delete medical records.
I’ve had experiences that have shaken my trust in institutions and governments handling sensitive information ethically, including having medical information shared without my consent by a hospital and it later being legally determined they did not violate my HIPPA rights in the process. I’m worried that my genetic information could be used against me, potentially leading to conservatorship or loss of financial autonomy. I’d like to avoid providing any legal documentation for the testing, if possible.
I’m also concerned about the security of genetic databases and the potential for breaches. Ideally, I’d like all records of the testing and medical records to be destroyed after completion to prevent unauthorized access.
Is there a way to ensure my privacy while getting the genetic testing I need? I’m open to exploring options in other countries, as long as I can ensure my privacy is protected. Please address only my privacy concerns related to genetic testing. I’m not interested in suggestions about mental health support or therapy at this time.
I do not authorize or approve of any unauthorized data scraping or AI training using this post; such actions would be unethical and without my permission.
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn’t great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don’t promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
- 0 users online
- 57 users / day
- 383 users / week
- 1.5K users / month
- 5.7K users / 6 months
- 1 subscriber
- 3.13K Posts
- 78.4K Comments
- Modlog
My best recommendation would be to go to a testing lab and provide a fake name. It should work. I’ve never been ID’d at any doctor’s office, and one time did even receive healthcare under a fake name with no trouble. Of course, that means your insurance won’t cover anything, but that’s the unfortunate reality of US healthcare. Also, they probably won’t delete your data. HIPAA includes no right to be forgotten, and in some cases, may even mandate retention for several years.
Sorry I don’t have a better solution. I think your best bet is to distance this genetic data as much as possible from your real identity.
Alternately, you could try going somewhere outside the US.
I completely agree that HIPAA is dead. One time when I went to a new doctor’s office, totally unaffiliated with any doctor I’d ever seen before, the doctor instantly pulled all my medical records from several other places. They didn’t even get my verbal permission; they just did it. If that’s the level of security on these databases, and doctors are allowed to access them on old unsupported Windows computers, then it’s almost certain that the databases have tons of undetected data breaches. They’ve probably been scraped completely by multiple attackers.
Well I mean your insurance won’t cover the cost of any DNA test that’s being done for heritage identification.
If they have ops dna then thats not anonymous. Though most likely they would only store positive/negative for a given condition—storing more genetic data than that just seems like a waste of storage space, especially since getting someone’s dna is fairly trivial for the state for most people who will leave hair and skin cells everywhere.
In the US I would have no right to delete my genetic profile there and with advances in technology my information would be likely linked to me, including databases that could be vulnerable to hacking. Using a fake name with my real genetic profile could not only get me added to a DNA database, but also a fraud database. I am concerned with losing independence and this is too risky.
I do not authorize or approve of any unauthorized data scraping or AI training using this post; such actions would be unethical and without my permission.
Yeah, it’s definitely a problem, and genetic information could end up getting linked. Even if a person thinks they might not have DNA in any existing database, whether criminal, medical, or otherwise, there’s no telling what might happen in the future. I can think of a few different ways a person might involuntarily, through no fault of theirs, get their DNA forcibly taken with no legal recourse.
Every path here will have some tradeoffs. But the odds of getting linked are probably much lower outside your home country.
HIPAA refers to a specific handling of medical information, not guidelines for privacy as you seem to think it does. If you went from one network doctor to another, your information can be pulled from that same system they all use. Nothing shady going on there.
I voted you down because HIPAA absolutely does include privacy provisions, and requires written consent for data use in the way I described above.
I have had history of medication shared with a centralized medication database for my state without consent.
Insurance companies also have medical data-brokers that they consult with when determining things like whether to accept people into life insurance policies or for determining certain premiums. How they get this information is not public, and they are not supposed to share it with commercial data brokers, but I never consented to be in that sort of database and likely am.
HIPAA has not provided me with the protection I want.
I do not authorize or approve of any unauthorized data scraping or AI training using this post; such actions would be unethical and without my permission.
Guess you must have reading comprehension issues then? I clarified exactly what I meant to say. The comment I responded to seems to think there’s some lockbox around your data that says it can’t go from doctor to doctor, and then I CLEARLY explained how it works.
Downvote yourself, friend.